1. My Brother's Girl: Part 3


    Date: 2/6/2017, Categories: Cheating, Author: OlDirtyBastid, Rating: 4, Source: LushStories

    sighed resignedly. “I’ll tell Mark I’m not feeling well or something.” “Good,” said Maddie. “I already told my dad I was going to hang out with a couple friends, so Mark won’t be all ‘hey where’s Maddie’ when he gets to the house and I’m not here. When will he be leaving?” “About fifteen minutes or so, I think.” “Okay. I’ll wait like twenty minutes then head over there.” I had a bad feeling about this. ******** I told Mark I’d have to beg off that day’s work, as my stomach was bothering me after the Mexican food I’d had the night before. He was a little cheesed that he’d have to take care of Maddie’s parents’ huge-ass grounds all by himself, but he cheered up a bit when I told him I’d already called one of our buddies to cover for me. He left, and about ten minutes later, Maddie showed up. We went into the living room and sat on the couch. She sat close to me, a little too close for my comfort. The way she was sitting, turned towards me, one leg curled beneath her, made her look unbearably cute. I was instantly aware of her presence and began to get turned on, as I always did when she was near me. Her eyes told me she was feeling it too. “What’s the emergency, Madds?” I began. “We finally did it last night,” she said. “Mark and I finally slept together.” Great. Just what I wanted to hear. “Congratulations,” I said. “I know you’ve been wanting to take things to the next level for a while. You must be thrilled.” “I have, and I am,” she said, her eyes downcast. “I sense a ‘but’ ...
    coming,” I said. She looked at me and smiled ruefully. “But… it wasn’t exactly everything I’d been hoping for. And that’s why I need to talk to you.” Half of me wondered why I needed to be part of this conversation, while the other half had a sneaking suspicion that I already knew the answer to that. “Wasn’t everything you’d been hoping for? What, is my brother a lousy lay?” I joked, trying to play it off. “No, not at all. It was good, it was special, it was everything your first time with your boyfriend is supposed to be… well, almost everything.” She looked deep into my eyes. “He didn’t get me off.” HELLS YEAH, my brain cheered. ‘CUZ HE AIN’T ME, BITCHES! Outwardly I tried to restrain my egotistical glee. “Oh damn, that sucks, Maddie. On behalf of the men of my family I apologize most sincerely for my brother’s utter failure to satisfy you sexually. Please accept my assurance that he is not the example by which we should be judged.” She slapped my arm. “Shut up, Dave. You know exactly what I’m talking about and you know exactly why and don’t pretend you’re not all happy about the fact that I couldn’t orgasm with your brother because he’s not you.” It felt good to hear her say it, but at the same time I felt sort of lousy. I honestly hadn’t wanted to do anything to come between them, but the attraction between Maddie and I was so powerful we couldn’t help it. “Maddie,” I said softly. “I wanted it so bad,” she said. “I had this idea that I’d finally have sex with my boyfriend ...
«1234...67»